Closing the Teach For America Blogging Gap
Apr 25 2010

New Immigration Law

(Edit: If you aren’t going to read this very long post, then at least let Colbert explain.)

I’m sorry I haven’t posted yet on the new Arizona immigration law. I know it’s made national news and has people telling me to leave Arizona and not look back. Most of the articles about it, like those printed in the Huffington Post, the New York Times, and yes, Fox News, make it sound like the state is going to become a mess of racial profiling and random arrests. I’ve heard plenty of references to Nazi Germany and Apartheid in South Africa. Personally, I’m pretty nervous about it, but I’m still undecided on exactly how upset I am. I’ve been reading and re-reading the actual text of the bill, because I still hold out hope that there’s no way this is actually as bad as the news says it is. I’m hoping that it has been sensationalized for the public, because I still have some faith that my legislators are at least a little sane.

The short version of the story is that Arizona is exhausted from trying to handle illegal immigration and doesn’t feel like the federal government is doing enough to help. This law takes matters into our own hands by calling it trespassing to be in the state (on public or private land) illegally. It gives local police a wider power to check immigration status and pass illegal aliens on to the federal government. (If the law passes constitutional muster, it will be because all matters are sent on to federal authorities, which is who is supposed to deal with illegal immigration anyway.) It makes it illegal for illegal aliens to work here, and illegal to pick up day laborers (if your car is blocking traffic). Police officers can stop people who they suspect of smuggling “for profit or commercial purpose.” It makes it illegal to entrap employers into hiring illegal aliens, and also requires that they keep records of the e-verification hiring process. It also establishes the Gang and Immigration Intelligence Team Enforcement Mission Fund, which takes the fines collected according to this bill.

But none of that is what’s infuriating people. Everyone I’ve talked to is panicked over two parts. The first is that police officers can randomly stop people and demand papers, which sounds like a slippery slope. (No, Governor Brewer, calling for good anti-racial-profiling training for cops is not reassuring me.) It also makes it illegal to transport or hide people if you know they are here unlawfully. These are the two really controversial parts because most people know that something needs to be done about illegal immigration in our financially-strapped state, but no one wants it to be this broad and extreme. We don’t want to all have to carry papers around, and we don’t want our cars impounded for giving a friend/a family member/a date/a student a ride home.

Here’s where I wish I were a lawyer. I can read this bill a million times, but I can’t figure out exactly how severe these two big parts are. First, the random stopping: police with “reasonable suspicion” can check immigration status… but only during “lawful contact”. WHAT ON EARTH COUNTS AS LAWFUL CONTACT? Can they just stop me walking down the street, like we’re all afraid of? Or do they have to be arresting me for something first?

The second is that it is “unlawful for a person who is in violation of a criminal offense to” transport or hide illegal aliens.  Does that mean I already have to be doing something wrong, so if I’m driving an illegal student home and a cop stops me for speeding, then they can also impound my car for transporting? Or does that mean that just by doing the transporting, I am automatically in violation?

True, the interpretation here would not determine whether or not I like the law, but it would make a big difference in how powerful it turns out to be. It would also make a big difference in how I explain their rights to my panicked students. If there are any lawyers out there reading this (or anyone better at googling “lawful contact” than I am… or just anyone with an opinion), I’d love to know what you think.

11 Responses

  1. stopdainsanity2

    Children are Watching

    by stopdainsanity2

    When I entered kindergarten – I was put into a class for the mentally retarded. Because my skin was brown my teacher assumed I did not speak English and required special bilingual support which was not available at the time. Yes – I was a Mexican-American citizen child AND I spoke English.

    It literally took 2 weeks for my parents to force the school to place me in the mainstream kindergarten class — even though I could respond to questions in English. At the time if was easier for frustrated- overworked teachers (not bad people) to send me to the special needs class – no questions asked – based on my skin color. Although the error was corrected, as a child I never lost the feeling I was not welcomed and somehow my rights as a citizen were not equal to those of white americans. Be careful – children are watching.

  2. Personally I think Arizona’s new law is a great law. We all recognize that we need to allow a better path to citizenship, but since the state can’t grant the citizenship the only way we can protect ourselves is to enforce harsher penalties against all illegal immigrants. We can’t sort the good and the bad until the Federal government acts. Instead of protesting our actions people should be petitioning their congressmen to reform immigration laws. We just want to keep the criminals and drug dealers out of our state.

  3. found it on google. nice. ill come back to visit.

  4. Isn’t this law basically a copy of existing federal law? Obviously the people of Arizona are alarmed at the rate of illegal immigrants that are spilling over their border with Mexico into the state. So what are they to do? Just sit back while the whole state implodes? It is clear the feds have no intention of honoring their duty to secure the border. So Arizona has to take these measures. It is a sad situation all around.

  5. Once again the media is showing it’s bias and support for the left wing by supporting illegal immigration while tearing at the very fabric of our Nation. I’m all for legal immigration but illegal immigration is and has been a huge drain on this country and it’s tax-paying citizens. I can’t believe I live in a day and age where Americans are called racists for defending the Constitution.Americans need to stand up and fight for thei rights and come to the realization that our country is under siege.

  6. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbour were preparing to do some research about that. We got a good book on that matter from our local library and most books where not as influensive as your information.

  7. Good topic for making an effective dissertation. . . . . .

  8. have been following ur website around several days. really like what you posted. by the way i’m doing a report regarding this issue. do you happen to know any great blogs or perhaps online forums where I can get more info? many thanks.

  9. Been browsing your blogposts for several. Only want to leave a comment say I absolutely love your web site. Cheers!

  10. Marvelous details, thank you to the creator.

  11. Its really a great post. I am sure that anyone would like to visit it again and again. After reading this post I got some very unique information which are really very helpful for anyone. This is a post having some crucial information. I wish that in future such posting should go on.

About this Blog

Middle School

Subscribe to this blog (feed)


[email protected]

This is usually a great Buy Cialis Online With Prescription merchandise. Cheap Generic Cialis I will be sixty-three and have absolutely sofosbuvir 400 mg prix used Cialis on and off approximately 36 Sofosbuvir Price months. Zero unwanted side effects whatsoever. My spouse cheap cialis and i consider blood pressure level supplements as well Buy Cialis as cholesterol capsules. Fifty percent any device may last us 2 days.

April 2010
« Mar   May »