# mathinaz

Closing the Teach For America Blogging Gap
Sep 03 2010

# Goodie Bags

“Ms. Mathinaz has 25 lollipops, 10 Tootsie Rolls, and 15 Smarties. She wants to divide them into identical treat bags for her students. What is the greatest number of bags she can make?”

Last year, I taught this kind of problem the straightforward way. We listed the factors, found the greatest common factor, and were done with it. If the question instead asked how many Tootsie Rolls were in each bag, we hopefully divided by the GCF. Unfortunately, this went poorly. My kids struggle to read, struggle to understand word problems, struggle to recognize that this is a GCF problem, struggle to find the GCF, and struggle with whether or not that’s the final answer. It’s already a difficult situation and I was trying to force a strategy they didn’t understand. I mean, if you’re reading this and not exceptional at math, can you describe to me exactly why GCF gives you the answer here? Because I have this feeling it isn’t just my kids who don’t fully get that.

So this year, I tried it differently. I didn’t tell my kids how to do it. I had them list factors beforehand, but they didn’t know what it was for and then we set them aside. Then I gave them a bag of pre-counted candy and a stack of cups to split them into. The kids split the lollipops in all possible ways and listed them. They repeated for the Tootsie Rolls. They repeated for the Smarties. Then they tried it with all three. They found the largest number of cups and wrote it down. After we did a couple activities like that, I asked them to check out the factor list we made at the beginning (the numbers were the same as the candy problems) and see if they saw a pattern.

*GASP!* The list we made is the same as the factors! The number of cups is the GCF! Ms. Mathinaz, I found a shortcut! We could have just found the GCF instead of doing all that work!

Yessssssssssssss conceptual understanding! It’s so much harder to teach than algorithms, but it’s something I’m committed to working on this year. I know that means I’ve got some bad lessons ahead of me (my principal wasn’t overjoyed by my LCM lesson, which did not run this well), but I think this one was a success and it makes me hopeful.

And the best part? I gave my kids a ton of delicious candy. I let them play with it for an hour. At the end of class, they returned it to me. Every single piece, and yes, I counted. Yay for trust and honesty. (And yay for extremely explicit expectations and a detailed plan for rewards and consequences if the candy plan went well or poorly.) Huge win. I love my kids.

## 5 Responses

1. FYI, it took me like a solid two minutes to figure out the answer to that question. Granted, I’m really bad at math. But don’t be too hard on your students

2. Beaver

I still don’t know the answer!!

3. Ms. Math

Keep up the good work on teaching conceptually! If you ever really want to discuss it you should come hang out with me in the math ed part of ASU. We’ve got some seriously awesome math ed professors in the math department there.

4. What a wonderful blog. I invest hours on the internet reading blogs, about tons of different subjects. I have to to begin with give kudos to whoever created your web site and second of all to you for writing what i can only describe as an post. I honestly believe there is a skill to writing articles that only several posses and to be truthful you have it. The combination of informative and quality content is definitely very rare with the big quantity of blogs on the internet.

5. good for you!!! it is SO easy to teach shortcuts and hammer things into kids’ heads and then say “well just memorize this, you dont have to worry about how it works” and get good short term results. but you are showing them to love and appreciate math!!

Sometimes I read this and think your name is actually Ms. Mathinaz

Region
Phoenix